News

This algorithm’s racial bias prevents black people from getting kidney transplants

With prejudice against black people already a major issue plaguing the US and the world at large, the last thing you need is for your algorithms to further exacerbate this problem. As it happens, a new study of chronic kidney disease patients in Boston found that the math used to diagnose individuals is very likely to assign black people healthier scores and thus prevent them from qualifying for a kidney transplant when they really need one.

The study in question analyzed health records for 57,000 people suffering from chronic kidney disease from the Mass General Brigham health system that comprises of Harvard teaching hospitals Massachusetts General and Brigham and Women’s. The study found that one-third of the black patients (more than 700 individuals) were diagnosed with a less severe category of kidney disease than what they were actually suffering from.

Of course, this kind of inaccurate diagnosis ends up affecting whether or not a deserving black person can get a kidney transplant or not. Indeed, in 64 cases, the recalculated scores for patients using a fairer formula would have qualified them for a transplant waitlist. However, since none of them were referred or evaluated for a transplant, it appears that doctors didn’t question the algorithm’s skewed results at all.

That was really staggering,” says Mallika Mendu, an assistant professor at Harvard Medical School. “We know there are already other disparities in access to care and management of the condition. This is not helping.

The sad fact is that this kidney disease algorithm is just one of the many clinical decision algorithms that factor race into their decision-making process. A recent review found more than a dozen such algorithms, including ones for critical conditions like cancer and lung care.

In order to address the issue of race as a factor in kidney assessment and care, two leading US kidney care organizations have formed a task force. Encouragingly, more than 1,300 people have signed a petition urging the group to take action.

Sponsored
Hamza Zakir

Platonist. Humanist. Unusually edgy sometimes.

Leave a Comment
Share
Published by
Hamza Zakir

Recent Posts

Pakistani Passport Continues to Rank Among the Worst in the World

According to the most recent Henley Passport Index, Pakistan's passport is still one of the…

7 hours ago

November 9 Approaches: Will Iqbal Day Be a Public Holiday This Year?

As Iqbal Day approaches on November 9, Pakistan prepares to honor Allama Iqbal, the celebrated…

7 hours ago

Most Wanted Human Trafficker Taken Into Custody

GUJRAT: According to the Gujrat circle of the Federal Investigation Agency (FIA), they have arrested…

8 hours ago

Air Sial Starts Weekly Flights from Islamabad to Riyadh

Air Sial, one of Pakistan's leading private airlines, has officially launched its weekly flights from…

8 hours ago

Important Update on Profit Rates for Savings Schemes 

On Friday, the government stated that from November 4th, 2024, profit rates on National Savings…

10 hours ago

Pakistan to Legalize Bitcoin and Cryptocurrency Through SBP Act Amendments?

The federal government has proposed amendments to the State Bank of Pakistan (SBP) Act aimed…

11 hours ago