When the recent protests against the government reached the peak this Sunday, several doctored images and misrepresented videos, began being tweeted as part of the hashtag – #CivilWarinPakistan which soon assumed the No.1 spot on Twitter. The trend suggested that a war-like situation was ongoing in Pakistan and that the armed forces personnel were resigning and had gone rogue. It was aimed at worsening the unrest by acting as fuel to the fire to further incite violence. The highly sophisticated mass propaganda and disinformation campaign had all the characteristics of state-sponsored 5th generation warfare, about which we have been sufficiently warned by the ISPR. But, have we done enough to control it and mitigate its disastrous consequences?
A 6-month-old video of a funeral procession in Lahore being presented as part of the recent protest
Let's get back POK & Sindh!
Civil War situation in Pakistan!
People on Roads, against the Army & the Selected Government!#CivilWarinPakistan #COVIDEmergency pic.twitter.com/9RL7hxhasN
— Nayan Taori (@nayantaori) April 14, 2021
An unnamed video of a Pakistan army soldier was later revealed to be fake
https://twitter.com/PakNews2021/status/1383887172252536837
An old video of Punjab police personnel leaving was linked to the current protest
https://twitter.com/TheZaiduLeaks/status/1383778245691072515
According to the renowned journalist, Makhdoom Shahab Uddin, the trend, #CivilWarinPakistan was created by an Indian Twitter account, @Gif_baaz at 2:00 PM and the majority of the Twitter accounts’ locations could be traced to Indian cities such as Pune, New Delhi, and Mumbai. All videos of army personnel
However, the participation by political parties’ workers in these trends only made matters worse.
Another senior journalist and anchor revealed that Indian elements had penetrated the WhatsApp groups of the protesting party’s workers and were inciting violence the Law enforcement agencies. According to him, the miscreants part of the network had been tracked and arrests of those instigating the protests were likely.
Some #Indian cell numbers have been found in what’s app groups of TLP members stroking and inciting violence against #Pakistan & its LEAs.. Security officials say they have tracked the network & arrests likely of some foreign passport holders instigating the protesters. pic.twitter.com/VyKEGSKFGD
— Arshad Sharif (@arsched) April 18, 2021
5th generation Warfare or Hybrid warfare is a military strategy that employs political warfare and blends conventional warfare, irregular warfare and cyberwarfare with other influencing methods, such as fake news/disinformation campaigns, and diplomacy. It has been largely used to define Indian efforts to destabilize Pakistan by exploiting its politico-religious fault lines by weaponizing mass media, including the broadcast channels, print mediums and social media. It has been frequently referred to as a major challenge by Pakistan’s premier security forces.
Director-General of Inter-Services Public Relations (ISPR) Major General Babar Iftikhar had declared that India is subjecting Pakistan to a massive campaign of fifth-generation warfare to inhibit the country’s success and tarnish its international image.
“Unfortunately, it’s a major onslaught, it’s a major part of the fifth-generation warfare. Pakistan is being subjected to […] hybrid applications massively and we are aware of that,” the ISPR director-general said. “Be it fake news spread by Indian sources of a ‘civil war’ in Pakistan or the propaganda being carried out against the nation on various social media platforms, the reality of our time is that this kind of warfare – aptly termed fifth-generation warfare – shapes our international relations significantly.”
Recent events highlight the pressing need for deterrence against various forms of fake news propaganda
Another legislation, “The “Citizens Protection (Against Online Harm) Rules, 2020” oblige social media platforms like Facebook, Twitter and Google to block or remove posts that are considered objectionable by the government as a means to monitor and mitigate online content related to “terrorism, extremism, hate speech, fake news, incitement to violence and national security.”
However, in situations like the one in Lahore yesterday, whereby real-time tweets, hashtags and WhatsApp messages were used, the government’s ability to act quickly and on time to identify the culprits whether local or overseas and have them blocked by the social networks seems doubtful.
Until robust measures can be adopted to curtail tactics part of the 5th generation warfare and the harmful propaganda it brings, the citizens must be stressed not to believe in, or forward any form of content they come across on social media without verifying it thoroughly.
